I'm posting this impulsively minutes after watching the 1st episode of Shadowhunters because I just need to talk about this.
Even though I didn't have too many expectations, this was disappointing. It could've been so so so much better. I had prayed it would be so so much better.
5 OUT OF 10 STARS
First of all, the effects.
This type of show, it needs to have good CGI, otherwise it all looks kind of ridiculous. And, guess what?
Bad CGI all around. It makes everything look laughable when they jump up and becomes smears of black on the screen (for too long, as well), or when the bad guys explode like that. And it lessens the impact.
I feel like they just killed video game characters, so
I'm hardly going to care/feel scared for them, am I? the substitute for blood is colorful energy looking stuff, for crying out loud!! I assume the rating made them go with this, but couldn't they at least make it look slightly more gritty?
I was kind of prepared for it because of the sneak-peeks but I had hoped that was an unfinished product. No luck there!
Then,
the narrative is really choppy, and is hardly helped by
editing that lingers a second too long before moving to the next shot. A second may sound insignificant, but
it's the difference between the shots flowing to the shots feeling choppy. I
saw every wrong cut. I noticed how the actors weren't standing quite where they had in the previous shots. These nuisances usually go unseen when the editing is meticulous. Not to mention there is no subtlety in this type of editing.
Note:
this will probably not bother people who are not film majors lol
But
back the the narrative. I felt like the show needed to stop jumping around between characters. Yes, it's cool that OH MY GOD MAGNUS but it didn't help to suddenly cut to him in the bar twice for short interactions that helped the plot not at all. Stick with Clary.
In fact,
I think they should have stuck with Clary the whole episode for the most part. Don't show me Jocelyn's past! Don't show me Clary as a shadowhunter child! Don't show me Magnus erasing her memory! No no no no!
You take all the mystery out of it!!!
Imagine how delicious it would've been to be confused together with Clary. To see her bump into Magnus and you see recognition in his eyes and dazed confusion in hers and you
know there is something there but theoretically (if you haven't read the novels) you don't know what. And if you
do know what then you can anxiously await for Clary to find out, which is where the flashbacks could come in. As
her memory returning. And it could be choppy and broken because her memory isn't clear.
That could've been so awesome. I would've loved that.
And hide Magnus's identity from us.
Let new viewers see him, but not know who he is so they're curious, and let old fans flail as he comes on screen and eagerly await the moment everyone come together and they learn that the cool warlock they hear about fucking
glitters.
Speaking of which,
the script was sometimes so blunt it hurt. It was like "pssst, look here" or "this is what you should think!"
Like Luke and Jocelyn. Dude, I don't need a character to "jokingly" tell Luke to marry Jocelyn already to establish their relationship. This does
nothing for me.
Show me this in their interactions. Show me him coming into the room and giving her a small touch, for example. Show him linger on her a second too long before moving to someone else. Show him hesitate on the answer button (not outright decline it) to make me see his inner struggle.
The scene when he tells Jocelyn "We'll tell her together" does more for their relationship than that cop telling him to marry Jocelyn or that he's already acting like a husband.
Show us that, don't tell!
These type of jests could come later on, after you established their relationship (in the past and in the present), and then it could mirror the viewers own feelings.
Instead, you are telling them what to feel.
Now, the acting.
Hands down the best actors were Jocelyn and the guy that melts to death. I believed in his pain.
I kid, I kid.
All the actors had really weak parts which were just highlighted by their good parts. Thankfully, they were good more than they were bad but when they were bad they went all out!
Hopefully, this will even out and become solid the whole time.
So, yes. I didn't agree with the direction they chose to tell the story, taking all the mystery out of things by showing us everything too early. But I'll probably tune in to see how this continues.
**I'd like to point out that I had no trouble with the changes they made to the plot. I actually liked them! :D
